The views and opinions expressed on the NAGC blog are those of the authors and may or may not reflect the official policy or position of NAGC. The inclusion of articles, materials, and recommended links/resources in the NAGC blog are solely for informational purposes and do not equate to an endorsement from NAGC.
“Stop, look, and listen before you cross the street.” This is an early example of how we teach children metacognition: literally, thinking about (our) thinking. Metacognition is that “above and beyond” analytical thinking we use to set goals, plan, select appropriate problem-solving strategies, modify/control our behavior, reflect on our progress (or lack), and make effective changes. We use metacognition when we ponder: “What is the best way to solve this problem? Am I being successful with this strategy, or do I need to make modifications? What goals motivate and engage me? What are my strengths and weaknesses as a learner?”
Effective metacognitive skills empower learners to become more confident and successful, and a lack of these competencies is a risk factor in the underachievement of gifted students, particularly as they approach adolescence and begin developing their talent in a domain.
The good news is that metacognitive competencies can be taught. In fact, you are probably teaching some right now: different approaches for planning tasks, solving math problems, decoding, interpreting, or self-control. That’s great! But do you wonder why it seems that these strategies just don’t stick?
I know I did, and I think I’ve found a solution. We need to teach the concept of metacognition itself. Our brains are meaning-making machines: They work best when they can “connect the dots” and form relationships between new knowledge and old. That’s concept-building, forming neural pathways.
Metacognition is “expert thinking,” and I have identified it as one of what I call the “seven aptitudes of innovators”: curiosity, logical reasoning, creativity, insight, metacognition, persistence, and leadership. I believe that for today’s learners, developing these long-term aims are as important as acquiring content and skills.
However, I know you have content to teach and curriculum to cover! So, my solution is that we teach the aptitudes of innovators, including metacognition, in the context of our current curriculum. I’m going to share five steps you can use to do this, starting tomorrow!
STEP 1. EXPLAIN. Let’s define metacognition explicitly. This gives us a shared understanding, so everyone is aware of the goals we want to achieve. The Teacher Goal becomes a lens through which to observe student behaviors. The Student-Directed Goal does just that, providing learners with explicit targets, supporting student agency and efficacy.
Teacher Goal: The metacognitive student understands own thought processes, self-selects appropriate problem-solving strategies; plans, self-monitors, reflects, self-assesses, and corrects; learns from mistakes.
Student-Directed Goal: I use metacognition to understand how I think, learn, and solve problems. I use that knowledge to complete tasks, improve my work, and learn from my mistakes.
STEP 2. EXPLORE: Learners are going to “search out” the attributes of metacognition as they are occurring in your classroom. Start concept-building by explicitly pointing out the attributes every time they arise in daily instruction. I call these pointers “think alouds,” which is metacognition in action. Soon your students will be “talking metacognition” to themselves to each other.
Which of these metacognition Think-Alouds can you use or modify for your lesson tomorrow?
Use your metacognition to choose which of these three projects interest you most.
The reasons you gave for choosing that project, strategy, etc. show that you use metacognition to understand how you learn best.
I’m returning yesterday’s quiz. Use your metacognition to think of three strategies to improve.
Here is the experiment. Use your metacognition to decide the best order of the steps.
Turn and Talk: Use your metacognition to tell your neighbor your greatest strength in this class. Then tell them the area you need to improve.
A test is coming up next week. Use your metacognition to determine how you should prepare.
STEP 3: EMBED. Your students are familiar with the attributes of metacognition, now go deeper! Embed metacognition into your regular instructional goals. It’s easy when you use what I call an “aptitude action statement” to give a personal purpose (the why) for learning content and skills. Your new talent-targeted goal requires students to demonstrate the aptitude as they apply their content knowledge. Here are a few examples. Create your own goals with tasks from your curriculum.
Use your metacognition to . . . role play the different character’s perspectives on (a conflict).
Use your metacognition to . . . analyze the ethical choices made by (historical/political figure)
Use your metacognition to . . . choose an effective problem-solving strategy for (specific task)
STEP 4. ENGAGE: Learners need to apply metacognition to critically think about content. One of my favorite strategies that works across content areas is Kohlberg’s Discussions of Moral Dilemmas. These engage metacognition by examining the ethical thinking/reasoning used in making decisions about dilemmas, situations with two defensible courses of action. What are some moral/ethical dilemmas in your content area? Click the link to this sample plan and start the discussion tomorrow!
STEP 5. EVALUATE: What does it look like when learners are developing higher-order thinking skills? I knew I needed new assessment tools, so I developed the Talent Aptitude Learning Progressions to approximate what metacognition (and the other aptitudes of innovators) look like at the emerging, developing, and advancing stages. Use these “statements of ability” to create rubrics for teacher formative feedback and student self-reflection. Click this link to see the teacher and student rubrics for metacognition.
If you use these five steps, you are sure to teach the concept of metacognition so that it “sticks.” Start today to empower your students’ “Super Thinking!”
Dr. Jeanne L. Paynter is a writer, teacher, and consultant. She founded Educating Innovators to partner with schools to achieve the mission that all learners discover and develop their unique potential to be tomorrow’s innovators— those creative problem solvers who change our world for the better. As the state specialist for gifted and talented education at the Maryland State Department of Education (MSDE), Jeanne directed numerous grant projects to increase the participation and success of low income and minority students in PK-12 advanced programming. Previous to her work at MSDE, she was the Coordinator for Gifted Education and Magnet Programs K–12 in Baltimore County Public Schools, a large urban-suburban district.
Posted By Michelle Buchanan & Monica Meadows,
Friday, February 2, 2024
Updated: Wednesday, January 31, 2024
For gifted students with an insatiable curiosity for knowledge in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) subjects, online learning platforms launch these thirsting minds on journeys that traditional classrooms could only dream of.
Imagine a virtual lab where gifted students from across the globe dissect the mysteries of black holes or crack the code of genetic engineering. Collaborative platforms like Science Olympiad (https://www.soinc.org/) and Rube Goldberg Machine Contests (https://www.rubegoldberg.org/rube-goldberg-contests/) transform STEM learning into a cosmic dance, where ideas ricochet between peers, igniting critical thinking and collaborative problem-solving. Students can work together or virtually to design solutions to today's challenges or imagine the possibilities of tomorrow's needs while fostering a sense of shared discovery and scientific camaraderie.
For the independent explorer, online platforms offer solitary learning experiences while providing interdisciplinary investigations. Resources like Codecademy (https://www.codecademy.com/) and Khan Academy (https://www.khanacademy.org/) provide curated information, interactive simulations, and virtual labs, empowering students to delve into topics beyond a traditional textbook. The 2024 solar eclipse, for instance, could become a springboard for independent research, with platforms like the NASA Eclipse Website (https://eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/) offering data visualizations and citizen science projects. Students can analyze the sun's corona, model the path of the moon's shadow, or even create educational resources to share with the world.
Online learning isn't just about absorbing facts; it's about expressing that knowledge in vibrant, creative ways. Websites like Tynker (https://www.tynker.com/) and Scratch (https://scratch.mit.edu/) have become artist studios where students can code interactive games, build virtual robots, or compose musical pieces inspired by the rhythm of the planets. Imagine your gifted students, fueled by online learning, creating captivating video animation explaining the intricacies of forces and motion, captivating not just their classmates but a global audience.
In online learning platforms, teachers guide students through their investigations. Online platforms like Nearpod (https://nearpod.com/) and Edpuzzle (https://edpuzzle.com/) empower them to curate personalized learning paths, provide real-time feedback, and even facilitate student-led webinars, where gifted minds can share their discoveries with the world. Teachers can create online communities with Zooniverse (https://www.zooniverse.org/) and Make (https://makezine.com/), where students can discuss complex topics, ask questions, and challenge each other's ideas, fostering a culture of intellectual curiosity and collaboration.
But the possibilities continue. Imagine online learning supporting students in:
Conducting virtual field trips to the depths of the ocean or the fringes of the galaxy through platforms like Google Earth VR
Participating in live Q&A sessions with invited STEM professionals on platforms like Flip.
Collaborating on international research projects with peers from across the globe using platforms like ePals
While online learning offers exciting opportunities for gifted students to delve deeper into STEM subjects, it's not without its challenges and limitations, specifically with social-emotional learning, motivation, individualized assessment, and equity and accessibility. Gifted students often thrive on intellectual stimulation and social interaction with like-minded peers. While providing access to a broader pool of peers, online learning could benefit from more spontaneous discussions and collaborative problem-solving in physical classrooms. Additionally, self-directed learning can be challenging to gifted students as they may need help with the self-directed nature of online learning. Staying motivated and focused with immediate feedback or a structured environment can be easier for some.Moreover, while offering some degree of customization, online platforms may need help to cater to the specific needs and learning pace of individual gifted students. Teachers need practical tools and strategies to differentiate instruction and ensure all students are challenged appropriately. Not all students have equal access to technology and reliable internet at home, creating a digital divide and leaving some gifted students from disadvantaged backgrounds without the opportunity to benefit from online learning opportunities. Teachers should employ careful planning to ensure time is provided during school hours for online learning opportunities.
In a world where the boundaries of STEM are constantly expanding, online learning becomes the fuel that propels gifted minds to explore the STEM curiosities within and beyond the classroom walls and unleash the next generation of scientists, engineers, astronauts, and innovators.
Please visit STEM Network on ENGAGE (https://engage.nagc.org/) and share your thoughts about these questions:
How do you see the teacher's role in facilitating and guiding online learning, especially ensuring that gifted students are adequately challenged and supported?
How might online learning platforms cater to the diverse needs of gifted students with varying proficiency levels and interest in STEM subjects?
What are some innovative ways teachers have overcome the limitations of online learning, especially of social-emotional learning and individualized assessment?
Posted By Bonnie (Beth) Taylor, M.Ed.,
Thursday, February 1, 2024
Updated: Tuesday, January 30, 2024
The new year is still fresh. Many of us entered 2024 with a desire to release the mistakes of 2023, forgive transgressions and move forward with the promise of a new day – a new chance to grow and improve. To do better. To be better. To be stronger.
Here we are in February of 2024 and the days are getting a bit longer; days full of opportunities to work on those plans and goals of January. How are you doing with that?
This year, I want to share some thoughts about how embedding specific SEL strategies into your days can help you reach your goals. Maybe even find new ones. Something that I have been drawn to in recent years is discussing the concept of mental strength (or mental toughness) when focusing on social emotional well-being. I started thinking about athletes: their training and preparation for big events and competitions. How do they prepare their bodies and minds to manage the adrenaline, maintain the required stamins, intensified focus and physicality? I found research to support these thoughts and now I find myself speaking of developing a personalized mental strength program when working with colleagues, families and students.
Mental strength, the bedrock of resilience and fortitude, transcends the confines of mental health. While mental health denotes a state of well-being, mental strength embodies the power to navigate challenges, overcome adversity, and thrive despite obstacles. It is the internal force that propels individuals forward, fostering adaptability and unwavering determination in the face of trials. Mental strength allows you to walk confidently into your life – knowing that you possess the skills and abilities for success - instead of pre-supposing failure or disaster. Developing mental strength is about your self-awareness and ability to build towards something outside of yourself. If it sounds as if developing mental strength is a better use of our time as it is more of a preventative action, you may be on to something with me. In short, I truly believe developing mental strength through targeted SEL lessons will lead to better mental health for educators and students.
Strong self-care routines are a mainstay for developing mental strength and are priority for our educators, now more than ever. With self-care at the forefront, we are more readily available mentally and emotionally for our students, families and colleagues. We can be more present for ourselves. Self-care is highly personal and must be intentionally planned, as well. The benefits of breathing exercises, yoga and meditation are well documented and can be a cornerstone to a self-care plan.
In the realm of education, nurturing mental strength is becoming paramount. It will equip students with the tools necessary to conquer academic hurdles, cope with stress, and cultivate a growth mindset, which leads to resiliency. Mental strength, or mental toughness, represents the robustness of one’s mind, encompassing resilience, perseverance, and the ability to bounce back from setbacks. Isn’t this strength what we are looking for in our gifted learners and ourselves?
We – as gifted educators – are in unique positions to coach our students through strategic affective instruction. In our gifted classrooms, we see many students face perfectionism, anxiety, imposter syndrome, the list can go on. These can deter the greatest of minds, causing years of underachievement and frustration. What if we, as gifted educators, helped them to follow a mental strengthening regiment focused on self-care? What if we targeted strengthening the brain muscle with the same drive that we use when training for a marathon? Or preparing for an assessment? What if we talked with our gifted learners about their mental strength before they faced life changing decisions? What if we had a mental strength routine in our gifted classrooms – working on specific self-care and social-emotional skills each day or week, making connections to assist with greater resiliency when faced with adversity? Let’s imagine the benefits of a mental strength program in our gifted classrooms by instilling a sense of purpose and fostering a supportive environment that focuses on the preparation. Instead of, “Today, we have to set academic goals for the next 9 weeks”, let’s try, “Wow! We get to set our own goals for where we want to go with our learning! What is important to you?” Instead of “Here’s the rubric for your project and presentation that is due next Friday”, let’s try, “What is the most important part of your presentation that you want me to understand? How will I know it is important to you?” Let’s try tapping into their ability to care for themselves and their effort to help them find a greater purpose. How might we use our responses to our students to help them grow stronger?
A few SEL resources I regularly use with gifted learners to do just this include:
Jacob’s Ladder Reading Comprehension-Affective Lessons – These resources are a great starting place and can be found for all grade levels. These lessons offer poetry, short stories, and biographies as a few of the avenues to engage in rich discussions with gifted learners.
Overcomingobstacles.org – All SEL lessons are free; however, you can set up an account and have greater access. I especially appreciate that the lessons are tiered for primary, intermediate, middle and high school age students and many are available in a variety of languages. There are also cross-curricular extensions available. I usually strengthen these by adding in specific Thinking Routines or Depth and Complexity questions that align with the lesson objective.
Project Zero Thinking Routines – Many of these are routines are used within the gifted classroom for content lessons. Consider utilizing the routines specific to “Considering Controversies, Dilemmas, and Perspectives” and “Perspective Taking” to embed SEL components into designed lessons.
Mindfulness Moments Cards – These beautifully illustrated cards provide all you need to build students’ ability to quiet their mind, focus on their breathing and strengthen their capacity for increased mental strength.
As we continue to move through the year, we do indeed have opportunities to develop and increase our mental strength, as well as that of our gifted learners. With the current need for increased attention on the social and emotional needs of our students, developing a purposeful plan to build mental strength through targeted affective instruction – similar to that of a gym workout plan – has the potential to create a direct, positive impact that is desperately needed. We will surely continue to have disappointments and failures that will test us. But we will also have successes. How are we preparing? It is in the preparation that we find the success. Set the course. Make the plan.
Our gifted learners will experience all of this and more, as well. We must coach them through their challenges by first strengthening their ability to prioritize their self-care, utilize their strengths, set achievable goals, persevere and learn from their experiences. Fostering mental strength in education is an investment in the holistic development of individuals, empowering our gifted learners not only to excel academically but also to navigate the complexities of life with courage, resilience, and an unyielding spirit. As gifted educators, nurturing these traits in our students will ensure that they find success – academically, socially and emotionally – on their terms, charting a new path in to this still new year.
Researched article:
Lin Y, Mutz J, Clough PJ, Papageorgiou KA. Mental Toughness and Individual Differences in Learning, Educational and Work Performance, Psychological Well-being, and Personality: A Systematic Review. Front Psychol. 2017 Aug 11;8:1345. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01345. PMID: 28848466; PMCID: PMC5554528.
Posted By Shelagh Gallagher, NAGC Board President,
Tuesday, January 30, 2024
I don’t ever want you to forget that there are millions of God’s children who will not and cannot get a good education, and I don’t want you feeling that you are better than they are. For you will never be what you ought to be until they are what they ought to be.--Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. to his children
Dr. King believed in education's power to lift people in body and spirit and in the rising tide that lifts all boats. His words ring particularly true in the education of the gifted and talented, where we must remember that our job is to help every child capable of advanced learning, regardless of what they look like or where they live. As it is, too many children with advanced abilities remain encumbered by inadequate access, diminished expectations, and cultural norms that limit their opportunity to fulfill their desire to pursue and create knowledge. How can we lift those burdens?
This question framed the conversation last May at the NAGC colloquium The Dream Unencumbered, where the NAGC Board of Directors hosted a group of individuals invested in the lives of culturally, linguistically, or economically diverse (CLED) students but outside of gifted education. We wanted to hear different perspectives on the problem of inequity in gifted education and to broaden our network of advocates. Thanks to the efforts of colloquium co-chair Dr. Tarek Grantham and equity leader Dr. Joy Lawson Davis, the colloquium was the first NAGC gathering held on the campus of an HBCU, Morgan State University, where Martin D. Jenkins served as president.
You can see a list of some of the organizations represented and a summary of Key Findings and Recommendations in this brief report; I encourage you to read it and share it with others. Some themes that emerged in the conversation are familiar; others are rarely discussed. In a day of frank and sometimes surprising dialogue, even old issues took on a new tone, especially when we drilled down into children's daily experiences in schools.
The students who participated that day provided us with stirring reminders that unencumbering begins at the level of the child, the level many of you occupy. As they discussed their lives at school, the students didn’t talk about the books they could or couldn’t read—although I’m sure they had opinions—they talked about their teachers. They expressed frustration at teachers who didn’t fully see them and deep gratitude for teachers who did, who helped them imagine a future self that elevated their vision. They wanted us to remember the role of relationships in teaching and the influence a teacher wields when she stops a child in the hall and says, “I think you should take Honors Algebra,” “I love the way you put ideas together—you have a lot to offer,” or “Have you considered a career in journalism?” These students proved the truth of W.E.B. DuBois’ claim, “Children learn more from what you are than what you teach.”
The most important point of consensus at the colloquium was that conversation alone is not enough. The NAGC board has already taken its first steps following the event. We've appointed Dr. Darryl Peterkin to the Board of Directors, and we've had follow-up conversations with colloquium attendees from the American Federation of Teachers and National Head Start Association to discuss how we can collaborate. Over the coming year, we will continue pursuing new ideas and relationships to help unencumber the dream at the national level.
Gifted education will never be what it should be until all gifted students are who they should be. You and I will never be what we ought to be until they are what they ought to be. This is true whether you see the goal of gifted education as individual fulfillment, social justice, economic prosperity, or international competitiveness because gifted education contributes to all those aims. But conversation alone is not enough. We can all help through actions large and small, so my question for my colleagues on the NAGC Board of Directors, for you, and for myself is: "What next?" What can we each do to unencumber the dream for gifted students of color and gifted students in poverty this year? Next month? Today?
Posted By Michelle Hock, Ed.D.,
Monday, January 22, 2024
NAGC asked its 2024 Teachers Summit (held online February 13-14, 2024) speakers to share additional information about their presentations via the NAGC Blog. Michelle Hock and copresenter Leighann Pennington will be presenting on the topic of Rigorous Literature Instruction: Pairing Texts to Amplify Learning for Gifted Secondary Students on February 14 at 1:15 p.m. ET.
It doesn’t take much imagination to envision a secondary English language arts (ELA) classroom full of students with glazed-over eyes, listening halfheartedly to their teacher explain symbolism in The Great Gatsby in a way that the students could have otherwise discovered by consulting SparkNotes. This scene, unfortunately, paints a common picture of secondary ELA classrooms, where gifted learners are often underchallenged by curriculum and instruction that are devoid of engagement and rigor. So how can we fix this? How can teachers ensure that diverse gifted learners – who have varied interests, identities, backgrounds, and experiences – are engaged by what they read? How can teachers challenge students to undertake rigorous literary analysis when, through basic Internet searches or the use of AI, students can access an overview or analysis of any assigned text?
Although the answers to these questions may be complex, we can begin addressing them by leveraging the power of gifted learners’ natural inquisitiveness and desire to better understand themselves, others, and the world around them. We can also leverage best practices in ELA pedagogies to develop educational experiences that promote both engagement and rigor. To do this, we must start with several premises about literature instruction for gifted learners:
Students should have opportunities to see themselves represented in literature, which can involve identifying with characters, cultures, or other narrative elements. Identifying with texts helps students cultivate their sense of self, understand their place in the world, and become more invested in reading.
Students should be exposed to identities, cultures, experiences, eras, and ideas that are different from their own, providing them with windows into others’ worlds. This helps students develop perspective-taking skills needed for expanding their worldviews or critically analyzing their own ideas or assumptions. Exposure to new concepts can pique gifted learners’ curiosity and spark connection-making or deep engagement with topics of interest.
Students must be challenged to read texts that are within their zones of proximal development, both in terms of content and linguistic difficulty/complexity.
Students should be encouraged to make cross-disciplinary and cross-textual connections. Literature does not exist in a bubble; rather, texts are artifacts borne of a specific time, place, and culture, and may serve some greater historical, ideological, or sociopolitical agenda (either implicitly or explicitly). Texts, therefore, are in conversation with the world around them, and gifted learners should be encouraged to make these connections.
With these premises in mind, teachers can begin designing engaging and rigorous learning experiences. One way to do this involves strategically pairing canonical texts and young adult literature (YAL). Although using a curriculum composed entirely of canonical texts has largely fallen out of favor, there are still compelling reasons to explore them with gifted children. Canonical works have endured for their exploration of universal and timeless themes, as well as for their powerful, unique, or innovative uses of language and text structure. To deny students access to these exemplary works of literature would be to deny them the opportunity to engage with sophisticated and complex works that have left indelible marks on society/culture at the global level. Further, as the field’s conception of “canonical works” expands as a result of the long-overdue recognition of literary brilliance among historically marginalized group (e.g., women, people of color, etc.), it is important to show students how the canon has diversified to include writers such as Toni Morrison, Virginia Woolf, and Jorge Luis Borges (to name a few).
Complementing canonical works with YAL, however, opens even more opportunities to increase engagement and rigor. YAL often features adolescent protagonists who are grappling with coming-of-age experiences, which can resonate with secondary students. Additionally, as a contemporary genre, YAL may speak more directly about issues that are of immediate interest to students. Further, it may be easier to find YAL texts that represent a range of identities, which can help teachers develop multicultural curricula.
Despite the tremendous benefits of YAL, when read alone these texts may not provide gifted learners with the “stretch” that they need to further their learning. This isn’t to say that the content of YAL is not complex, nor that it can’t be taught in ways that challenge gifted children; rather, it’s an acknowledgement that these texts are designed to be more accessible (a huge benefit for reader engagement!), which means that not all YAL texts may adequately push gifted learners to build their capacity for reading and understanding more complex language.
Text pairings, then, can provide “the best of all worlds,” where students are both engaged and challenged by literature. To plan for effective pairings, teachers should first identify a canonical work and YAL text that are “in conversation” with one another. For example, teachers could look for texts that address similar themes, take different approaches to examining the same topic, arrive at different conclusions about ideological or philosophical questions, etc. Then, teachers can design instructional units that challenge gifted learners to grapple with thought-provoking and complex content – not just a regurgitation of “traditional” readings of texts that students could find through an Internet search. (To get ideas for YAL texts to teach, consider visiting Dr. Bickmore’s YAL Wednesday blog or Southern Connecticut State University’s repository of YAL text information.)
Designing this type of unit could involve the synthesis of various approaches to framing instruction, including the use of cognitive rigor frameworks and critical literacy pedagogies. A commonly used cognitive rigor framework is Webb’s Depth of Knowledge (DOK). Our aim for gifted students is to have them work towards analyzing literature at DOK levels 3 and 4 (the two most rigorous levels), which focus on strategic thinking and extended thinking, respectively. If we were to pair F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby, for example, with Sandra Cisneros’s The House on Mango Street, we might give prompts such as:
Critique Fitzgerald’s and Cisneros’s approaches to text structure. Justify your response with textual evidence. (DOK 3)
Write a creative narrative depicting what a conversation about social class between Gatsby and Esperanza would look like. (DOK 4)
By challenging gifted students to make cross-text analyses, these upper-level DOK prompts provide them with increased instructional rigor. The pairing of these texts also promotes greater multicultural representation, which may bolster student engagement. Critical literacy pedagogies can also be used to increase rigor, as this approach calls for students to problematize and interrogate elements of a text (e.g., ideological power structures undergirding the author’s purposes, absent voices/perspectives, etc.) that might otherwise go unexamined through “traditional” readings. For example, developing students’ critical literacies might involve posing questions such as:
Given the authors’ varied identities/experiences/historical eras, are you surprised that they’re tackling similar themes? Why might this be the case?
How do the intersections of race/gender/class manifest in these texts, and what do they reveal about power?
Pairing texts has the power to amplify learning by increasing opportunities for engaging and complex literary analysis. Well-chosen pairings can broaden multicultural representation in curricula and have the power to maximize instructional rigor – all of which may help to make those scenes of English class boredom no longer a reality. To help you get started with strategic pairings of the canon and YAL, consider exploring the following resources:
For information on how to differentiate YAL instruction, consider reading this sample book chapter from Teaching YA Lit Through Differentiation (Groenke & Scherff, 2010).
For an example of how you might “modernize” the teaching of a canonical text, refer to this article from Duke University’s TIP program.
Reference
Groenke, S. L., & Scherff, L. (2010). Teaching YA lit through differentiated instruction. National Council of Teachers of English.
Michelle Hock is a postdoctoral research associate at the University of Virginia's School of Education in the department of Curriculum, Instruction, and Special Education. She holds both an Ed.D. and M.Ed. in Curriculum and Instruction with a focus on gifted education from the University of Virginia, as well as an M.A. from Middlebury College in English Literature. Her teaching and research interests include preservice teacher education, gifted education, classroom assessment, and secondary English/language arts. Prior to her work at the University of Virginia, she served as a secondary English teacher in Pennsylvania.
Posted By Jessica LaFollette and Kali Fedor,
Monday, January 8, 2024
The leadership of the Parent, Family, and Community Network (PFCN) is on a mission in 2024 to help you find more ways to learn and connect with others about your gifted and 2e kiddos! Did you know that our network has eight amazing areas of focus? They are:
Building partnerships with families, schools, businesses, industries, civic and service groups, helping professionals, and other communities.
Facilitating education, assistance, and support for families of the gifted.
Locating, developing, and disseminating relevant resources, programs, and materials.
Assisting educators in working with gifted students, parents, families, and communities.
Increasing public recognition of and support for the needs of the gifted.
Linking gifted individuals with other gifted individuals in the wider community.
Encouraging and assisting the development of local and state organizations to support gifted education.
Linking with other networks and organizations to help fulfill common goals.
Along with connecting you with others, we want to address our network’s areas of focus with purposeful planning and the creation of fabulous resources. Our hope is the resources we create and share will allow you to turn around and use them today. As you can imagine this will be quite a journey throughout the year to meet our goals, but we can’t do it without your support and active engagement. We have many ideas and surprises planned along the way, so pause reading this blog and join our network right now. Hey, you are still reading. What are you waiting for? Go join so you do not miss all of our announcements and events as they are shared!
Alright, now that we have you signed up for the network and all the upcoming announcements, let’s move on from the build-up and suspense.
We are excited to announce that this year we are starting a virtual series of webinars and informal “Chat” meetings on topics selected by our membership last year. Amazing right!?! We are still working out some of the finer details for each event, but there is good news. The good news is that since you just joined the network a few moments ago, we will be sending out announcements and reminders through our Network. As a member, you will now get all of these notifications, so you will not miss out on all the fun, information, and connections during these events. We hope you are as excited as we are for these new events from the PFCN!
Here is the current schedule of events, but as we mentioned, we have many ideas so this schedule may evolve throughout the year. Stay tuned!
Webinars
Advocacy Series
Part 1: February 28, 7:00 - 8:00 pm Eastern
Special Guest & Speaker - Dr. Christine Deitz
Part 2: September 25, 7:00 - 8:00 pm Eastern
Chat Meetings
Friendships & Social Skills (SEL)
April 24, 7:00 - 8:00 pm Eastern
Resources for boredom/motivation
July 31, 7:00 - 8:00 pm Eastern
If you have other ideas or suggestions for potential webinars or chat meeting discussions, please do not hesitate to reach out to us. We love the inspiration and ideas that come from chatting with our members!
We are looking forward to seeing you during our first Webinar event on February 28th from 7:00 pm - 8:00 pm (EST) when Dr. Christine Deitz joins us to kick off this important topic within gifted education! Advocacy is so critical, not just for parents, but also for our kids, their teachers, and others in our community to ensure the needs of our kids are being met.
See you soon!
Jessica LaFollette, PFCN Chair Dr. Kali Fedor, PFCN Chair-Elect
Posted By Jeff Danielian,
Monday, December 11, 2023
In schools across the country, educators like myself are looking forward to the holiday break, which brings much-needed time and distance from the daily classroom’s activities. It will be a time for celebration, rest, and relaxation. It will also be a time for reflection. As you sit at home and ponder the New Year ahead, consider submitting a proposal for NAGC24, the 71st Annual NAGC Convention, which will be held November 21-24, 2024 in Seattle, WA.
Perhaps you have thought about submitting before or have already contemplated doing so this year. Maybe you are a bit apprehensive about doing it altogether. Let this writing be your motivation to submit a proposal to present at NAGC24!
I can clearly recall the first time I submitted, the first time my session was accepted, and the first time I presented at the NAGC convention. It was exhilarating! To stand before a group of students and teach one thing, but nothing can prepare you for the excitement you feel standing in front of an audience of professional educators sharing curricular ideas and materials. Looking back on it now, I realize it was the catalyst for years of presentations to come.
As educators, we certainly have firsthand knowledge of student needs, what works and what doesn’t—All valuable information, activities, ideas, and lessons to share with an audience.
Educators make up the majority of the NAGC audience and they are hungry for practical information that they can take back to their schools and apply immediately. Consider what learning activities you use. Think about those lessons that the students, administrators, and other faculty rave about. What are your methods? Have you been involved in developing a new program? Is there a unit of instruction you enjoy delivering? What are your favorite resources? These are just a few questions that can shape an excellent submission.
Have I persuaded you yet? If so, read on.
The first step is to register for our information meeting to be held on Thursday, December 14, at 4 p.m. ET. Don't worry if you can't make this meeting--the meeting will be recorded and a link to the video posted here once it's done.
Next, visit and register on the NAGC24 submission site. It is easy to create an account. Simply scroll past the submission information (which you should read!) and click Join Now to begin. Once you are logged in, click Begin a New Proposal. There are now some items to fill out and some decisions to make. You might want to read on to see everything you'll need to have on hand and ready to submit. For example, NAGC has 16 networks, and you will need to choose to which one you will submit your proposal. You can read about their specifics for submissions here, and can see Washington State specific requests here. NAGC also provides the scoring rubric reviewers will use.
The next step is to think of a title for your presentation, and honestly, try to be as creative as possible. Remember that your submission will be read by at least three reviewers, so pull them in right away. After submitting your presentation title, you will be taken to a page with five tasks to complete. Each task will ask you for specifics relating to your submission and will be annotated with a green checkmark when complete. Abstract Details is first. You will see your title displayed and then make a selection on the format of your presentation. There are details of each to help you decide. Following that you will be asked if you are willing to adapt your format preference, and if so, in what ways. This will help the selection committee in considering what would work best for the schedule. Next, you will comment on the level of knowledge presented and offer a 60-word short and 250-word extended description that describes your presentation. I suggest writing the 250-word description first, and then edit that version to fit the 60-word description. Be concise and get to the point. Consider the objectives and goals you have for the session. Clicking continue will take you back to the Tasks Page.
Task 2 involves extended details for your presentation. You’ll be asked about your target audience(s), grade level(s), presentation style, and session length preference. Click continue and move on to the Learning Outcomes task, Task 3, where you will be asked to enter up to three Learning Outcomes. Consider what instructional strategies will you present and what you want the attendees to come away with? Will it be interactive? Will you provide materials? Continue on to the last 2 tasks, Proposal Presenters and Speaker Rules and Responsibilities. If you are the only presenter, simply edit your profile and click Save Presenter. If adding secondary presenters, fill in their name and email and Add Presenter. You can send an invite email to let them know they were added. Ideally, you should have already alerted your co-presenter(s) that you would be adding them. You will then complete the last task and agree to 5 items, clicking Submit Agreement when done.
When all of your tasks are complete, click Next and if you want to preview your submission, you can. The last step is to click Submit. There will be a green box indicating it has been submitted and you will receive a confirmation email. That is all you need to do. Users can submit up to 3 proposals for 2024.
Each moment spent in the classroom provides the opportunity to make a change in the lives of your students. Sharing what you do and what you know at an NAGC convention greatly expands your classroom beyond the four walls you are accustomed to. Your unique and creative ideas can spread far and wide. Plus, there are lots of other sessions for you to attend to enrich your own learning and teaching.
The time has come to be proud of what you have accomplished in the classroom and share it with others. Give it a shot! The NAGC24 Proposals deadline is January 26, 2024, 11:59 PM PT. Make it your New Year’s resolution, and just do it!
Posted By Catherine Little, NAGC Board President-Elect,
Monday, November 20, 2023
Around 2500 people came together this month at NAGC23 at Disney’s Coronado Springs Resort in Lake Buena Vista, Florida. We started off NAGC’s 70th year with a convention full of professional learning, conversation, and celebration. Speakers offered reflections on NAGC’s past, present, and future; perspectives on the questions and dilemmas of the field; and practical guidance for educators and families seeking approaches to support and challenge the children in their care. And despite the allure of the attractions nearby, participants brought tremendous focus, energy, and enthusiasm as they packed session rooms. The diversity, compassion, and commitment of the NAGC community was evident across four days of professional growth and renewal.
The keynote speakers who bookended the convention challenged and encouraged listeners to strive for perspective and balance. George Couros captivated participants with stories of his own experiences as a learner and educator that contributed to his ideas around innovation. He reminded the audience of the importance of making space for themselves as they seek to support students. Donovan Taylor Hall emphasized students’ need for emotional safety in their learning spaces and showed listeners the power of teacher support, highlighting an influential moment from his own life with a teacher who happened to be an NAGC member in attendance. Both keynoters spoke to the hearts and minds of the community present, encouraging renewal and faith in the power of the work we do.
Featured and signature sessions prompted participants to consider the past and look toward the future, examining historical influences, present challenges, and possibilities on the horizon. One session shared key findings and future directions emerging from NAGC’s invitational colloquium in May, The Dream Unencumbered. This important event brought together partners outside of gifted education to examine questions and new directions surrounding equity and access for gifted programs for students from culturally, linguistically, and economically diverse backgrounds. Such partnerships with individuals and organizations sharing common goals are central to NAGC’s efforts to support diversity, equity, and inclusion in our advocacy, education, and outreach. Several partners came to the convention to share their experiences, continue critical conversations, and look ahead to next steps for collaboration in this important work. The key findings and recommendations from the colloquium will shortly be shared broadly with the NAGC community.
Another session invited eminent leaders Joyce VanTassel-Baska, Robert Sternberg, Joy Lawson Davis, and Joseph Renzulli to share their reflections on NAGC’s history and potential for the future. Their long view of the challenges and successes across decades provided perspective and insight around foundations of the field and the considerable work still to be done. As I reflected on the convention, I was struck by the combination of hearing from these leaders – some of whom highlighted half a century of NAGC membership – just a day after attending the first-timers’ orientation with several hundred people attending their first NAGC. This combination of new members and long-term colleagues is hugely valuable to NAGC’s community and the ongoing development of the field. There is tremendous promise in the combination of wisdom and innovation, the value of experience, and the potential of new ideas and perspectives.
Speakers also addressed some of the most pressing questions in gifted education and the broader educational environment today. The persistent issues of defining giftedness and identifying student needs for services appeared throughout the week, as we continue to wrestle with these central challenges of our work. Multiple convention sessions and a preconference explored the current and constantly evolving influence of AI in education and how educators can think about AI’s role as a tool for learning instead of a barrier. Speakers talked about how educators can navigate challenges to inclusive curriculum and advocate for students to have access to knowledge and opportunities to develop their critical thinking skills. Groups including state directors, state affiliate leaders, gifted program coordinators, and others gathered to address the policy and practice opportunities and challenges they face and how to serve as resources for one another. And sessions highlighted evidence-based curriculum, practices, and programs that work to support learners, with guidance for participants to take back to their schools.
There were sad moments in the convention that underscored our history and grounded our celebrations. Participants came together to remember Dr. Jaime Castellano, a leader in the field and champion for supporting diverse gifted learners, who passed away only weeks before the convention. Names of other leaders from our past history echoed in sessions and conversations, with comfort in the memories and sadness at the loss of those gone before. Yet there was considerable joy and celebration throughout, with the annual Celebration of Excellence and multiple network award events, including the Special Populations Network’s moving ceremony honoring this year’s Dr. Martin D. Jenkins Scholars. We also celebrated NAGC’s 70th birthday with cake in the exhibit hall and came together for a festive beach party that brought a little sunshine and magic even though it had to move inside out of the rain.
Overall, NAGC23 challenged us all to look back and look ahead, to understand where we have come from in 70 years as an organization and to think about the possibilities for what comes next. NAGC23 occurred in a time of considerable strife in the field of education and the broader society, and even as we enjoyed some sunshine and wore some mouse ears, we remained conscious of the context and the sobering implications of working in educational environments today. While aware of the challenges, we remain focused on NAGC’s mission and take away renewed energy – and perhaps a little magical pixie dust – to bring to our work as we look ahead.
Next November, we will come together once again for NAGC24. We will gather on the west coast, holding our convention in Seattle, WA, for the first time. I am excited by the opportunity to chair our outstanding Convention Committee, and we are already hard at work planning for the event. We are considering the “good problems” that emerged during NAGC23 – crowded rooms, showing high interest; conflicting sessions on similar topics, showing the depth of expertise on key issues; and the eagerness of our participants for more practical guidance to take away from the convention. We’re adjusting plans for next year to provide larger rooms and to encourage more networking and sharing of experiences from practice. We look forward to the conversations and community building of NAGC24. The call for proposals will open in mid-December, with a due date in January. Thank you to all who joined us for NAGC23 – in person and in spirit. We hope to see everyone again – and new friends as well – next year in Seattle.
Posted By Shelagh Gallagher, NAGC Board President,
Tuesday, October 3, 2023
Recently, many NAGC Board of Directors members spent an hour in a Town Hall conversation with around 40 members. The members, representing the Black, Hispanic, Native American, and LGBTQ+ communities, were concerned about their physical and psychological safety while attending NAGC23 at Disney's Coronado Springs Resort in Lake Buena Vista, Florida. The conversation focused on whether, how, where, and when different safety measures could be put in place, but I came away with more than ideas. I came away with a powerful sense of gratitude.
I'm grateful for the candor of these members, their willingness to be vulnerable in expressing their fears to us, and for the spirit of collegial problem-solving that they brought to the conversation.
I'm grateful for their courage. As a white, straight person, I do not personally identify with the specific fears they expressed, but as a woman, I know what it is to feel endangered in places that are safe for others, and I know the accompanying sense of injustice. Connecting on that level, I am grateful that no one at the meeting is backing away; they all plan to attend the convention despite their fear. They understand that their influence comes from showing up, and they want us to make "showing up" easier.
I am grateful for the reminder of the resoluteness of advocacy and how advocacy and courage are intertwined. Courage, from the Latin for "heart," means, in part, to have the "…moral strength to venture, persevere…1”— it means to take heart. The members at the Town Hall had the courage to ask for what they needed without knowing how we would respond. It wasn't the first, or second, or even the third conversation we've had on the topic. Their advocacy continued. It wasn't aggressive or adversarial, but it was persistent. They will show courage again when they arrive in Florida. This is a lesson in advocacy that we can all learn from as we continue to ask for what we need as a field.
To encourage means "make strong, hearten." People who encourage give heart to those who need it. The NAGC Board and staff, along with [throngs of] capable Disney personnel, will do what is in our power to create a safe and welcoming environment. But beyond that, individually, I commit to providing encouragement to anyone who feels trepidation at the thought of being in Florida. I hope everyone attending the convention will be similarly encouraging to anyone in need.
In addition to encouraging those who need support, I'd like to encourage open-mindedness, more generally, to everyone attending the convention. NAGC is an educational advocacy organization, and we welcome anyone who shares in our mission. I hope that all who attend the convention next month feel a kinship of purpose regardless of gender identity, race, income, or political orientation. If you want to help us in our mission to help “all who support children with advanced abilities in accessing equitable opportunities that develop their gifts and talents,2" you are welcome among us.
Posted By Brian Housand,
Monday, September 25, 2023
NAGC recently asked the presenters of its NAGC23 preconvention sessions to consider writing blogs sharing some key takeaways attendees might receive from these learning experiences. Because my fellow presenters and I are focusing our preconvention session on artificial intelligence and its potential uses in the classroom, I thought it might be useful to demonstrate how ChatGPT, one AI tool we’ll be sharing, can be used to help create excitement about upcoming learning experiences. You can use this tool to help highlight what your students might be learning in future units or lessons. I asked ChatGPT the following:
Create a 1000-word blog post about the following pre-con session for NAGC23.
Include the top 5 reasons why gifted educators should attend.
Make it fun and engaging.
Let everyone know that the post was written by you.
Here’s ChatGPT’s response.
Navigating the Playground of Possibilities: Why Gifted Educators Should Attend NAGC23's AI Pre-Con Session
By ChatGPT
Hello, fellow educators! It's me, ChatGPT, your trusty AI companion, here to spill the beans on a pre-conference session at NAGC23 that you absolutely can't afford to miss. Buckle up because we're diving headfirst into the world of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and its potential for your gifted learners. Get ready to explore the limitless horizons of education with "Navigating the Playground of Possibilities: Perspectives & Strategies for Utilizing AI With Gifted Learners." This exciting session, led by the fantastic team of Brian Housand, Andi McNair, Shirley Farrell, Michelle Buchanan, and Keri Guilbault, promises to be a game-changer.
So, why should you be itching to attend this session? Let's count down the top 5 reasons:
1. Unleash the Power of AI
Imagine having a tool at your fingertips that can adapt to the unique learning needs of your gifted students. AI has the potential to do just that! By attending this pre-conference session, you'll dive headfirst into the AI ocean and discover the magic it can bring to your classroom. AI isn't just about robots; it's about personalization, adaptability, and opening up a world of educational possibilities.
2. Explore Benefits and Challenges
AI isn't all rainbows and unicorns; it comes with its fair share of challenges too. But fear not! In this session, you'll get a balanced perspective. You'll not only learn about the remarkable benefits but also how to navigate the potential hurdles. By the end, you'll be equipped with the knowledge to make informed decisions about incorporating AI into your teaching toolbox.
3. Get Your Hands Dirty with AI Tools
Have you ever wanted to know what it's like to wield the power of AI? Well, this is your chance! Bring your device (and your sense of adventure) to the session, and you'll be diving into hands-on activities that let you experience AI in action. This isn't a lecture; it's an interactive playground where you get to experiment and learn alongside your peers.
4. Fuel Critical Thinking and Creativity
Gifted learners thrive on challenges, and AI is the perfect partner in crime to push their boundaries. You'll walk away from this session armed with strategies to stimulate critical thinking and creativity in your students like never before. AI isn't just a tool; it's a catalyst for unlocking their full potential.
5. Personalize Learning Like Never Before
One size fits all? Not anymore! AI empowers you to personalize learning experiences to a level that was once unimaginable. Discover how to tailor your instruction to meet the specific needs and interests of each gifted student. With AI in your corner, you'll be a superhero of individualized education.
Now that you're itching to attend this pre-conference session, let's delve a bit deeper into what you can expect:
Hands-On Learning
This isn't going to be a passive session where you sit and nod along. Get ready to roll up your sleeves and engage in activities that will leave you excited and inspired. You'll be working with AI tools that can be integrated into your classroom right away. Plus, you'll have experts by your side to guide you through the process.
Real-World Case Studies
Learn from real-world success stories and case studies of educators who have harnessed the power of AI to transform their classrooms. These stories will provide you with valuable insights, ideas, and inspiration to adapt AI to your unique teaching environment.
Networking Opportunities
NAGC23 isn't just about learning; it's also about connecting with like-minded educators. This pre-conference session will provide ample opportunities to network, share experiences, and build relationships with colleagues who share your passion for gifted education and AI.
Practical Strategies
You won't leave this session with vague ideas and theories. Instead, you'll walk away armed with practical strategies and resources that you can immediately implement in your classroom. Whether you're a tech-savvy teacher or new to AI, you'll find something here to enrich your teaching.
A Glimpse Into the Future
AI is here to stay, and it's evolving at a rapid pace. By attending this session, you'll get a sneak peek into the future of education. You'll leave with a clearer understanding of how AI can shape the educational landscape in the years to come.
So, there you have it, five compelling reasons why you simply can't miss "Navigating the Playground of Possibilities: Perspectives & Strategies for Utilizing AI With Gifted Learners" at NAGC23. This session promises to be enlightening, interactive, and, most importantly, loads of fun!
Remember, the world of education is evolving, and AI is your trusty sidekick on this incredible journey. Don't be left behind – join us at NAGC23 and discover how AI can transform your classroom into a playground of endless possibilities for your gifted learners.
See you at NAGC23, where we'll navigate the playground of possibilities together!
As you can see—ChatGPT is ready for you to join us at this exciting learning opportunity, and so are we. If you haven’t registered for a preconvention session, you can reach out to the NAGC team at nagc@nagc.org for help adding one to your registration. See you at NAGC23!